TEXT:
This course
uses Open Educational Resources (OERs); there is no
book to purchase. The text, Discovering Truth: A
Primer in Epistemology by the instructor, is
embedded in the online Moodle class.
IMPORTANT: There is a quiz on the syllabus due
THURSDAY, April 9 by 11:59pm.
If you don't
take the Syllabus Quiz by the deadline, you may be dropped
from the course for non-participation. Try to
take this quiz early so you don't miss the deadline. If you
decide this class is not for you, please drop right away on
MyLane as there is
no
guarantee you will be dropped by the instructor.
This will also help out students on the wait list who would
like to add and get started with the class.
If you don't
drop by Sunday, April 12, 11:59pm, you will
be charged for the class. If you drop the class after
the 4th week, the class will be recorded on your transcript
with a "W" (withdrawn) next to it.
The absolute last day
to drop or change
your grading option to pass/no pass has been
moved to
Saturday, June 13 at 11:59pm due to
the coronavirus crisis.
CONTACTING THE INSTRUCTOR: Please
use Moodle messages to contact me. I
will do my best to reply within 24 hours. You may
receive a notification and copy of Moodle messages in your
email. Please don't reply to those directly; log
into Moodle and reply there. Using
Moodle messages consistently also allows us to track
any ongoing issues by scrolling up in the message
history. Replying
to email notifications or using email to contact me
will result in a delayed response and
the 24 hour rule will not apply. My students
come first; using Moodle for communication
will ensure your message gets the priority treatment
it deserves. Before contacting me, please review this
syllabus and and the Announcements Forum to see if
your question is already answered there.
THIS IS AN ADULT
LEARNING SPACE: Expect to come into contact with ideas
with which you disagree and to have your beliefs challenged.
Students will be treated as mature, responsible adults,
capable of engaging in adult conversations which may touch on
topics such as race, sex, gender, sexual orientation, sexual
relations, cultural differences, morality, politics and
religion.
It is a prerequisite of this course that you
possess, or be willing to develop, the ability to discuss
controversial issues in a calm, rational and respectful
manner.
ACADEMIC FREEDOM OF THE INSTRUCTOR: "The professional
freedom of faculty includes
the right to explore and
discuss controversial issues and divergent points of view,
including
evaluating, criticizing, and advocating their
point of view concerning the policies and programs of the
college..."-- Collective Bargaining Agreement between
the Lane Community College Educational Association and Board
of Education, Section 15.3. According to this section of the
faculty contract, the instructor is free not only to discuss
contentious, hot-button issues which have the potential to
offend you, but to approach them from viewpoints which diverge
from the mainstream and deviate from what you might consider
"acceptable" opinion. Academic freedom is essential to
fostering robust discussion of intellectual issues and the
social progress that results from such discussions. Before
reacting in knee-jerk fashion to an idea, please try to
remember that what offends our sensibilities is often a
product of our culture, mass media, upbringing, peer group and
personal history rather than any quality intrinsic to the idea
itself. Also keep in mind that these things change over time.
Many ideas that were considered dangerous, controversial or
offensive in the past are now part of the unquestioned status
quo. Your job as a thinking person is to sort feeling from
fact and to separate rationality and morality from cultural
prejudice and personal bias. This type of
self-examination
is a big part of what it means to be a
philosopher.
Faculty have wide discretion in how they treat academic
subjects in the classroom. Although this class will explore a
diversity of opinions,
some ideas will be emphasized over
others. Beliefs which enjoy institutional support from
the college may be singled out for scrutiny, as explicitly
allowed in Section 15.3 above. Ideas which predominate in
academic culture and the social sciences or among college
students may face special criticism, while
minority or
neglected viewpoints may be given special consideration.
This is because critical thinking is most important when it
comes to beliefs you are likely to have uncritically adopted
(or dismissed) due to various dominant social influences.
Considerations
of "balance" in this course are approached from the
institutional level. So, for example, if the college as
an institution and the majority of courses favor or promote
one view on a controversial issue, this class may balance that
out by emphasizing an opposing view.
The instructor attempts to give the best argument for many
different views.
Just because an argument in favor of a
particular view is given in class, podcasts, the text or
other external resources does not necessarily mean that it
is the instructor's view on the subject. In fact, you
may notice that the instructor will make arguments for views
which are logically incompatible with one another. Therefore,
it makes no sense to assume that every time a view is being
presented, the instructor believes it and is attempting to
persuade you to accept it.
It is up to you to sort through
the competing claims and arguments presented in this class
and decide for yourself which views to accept.
If you disagree with or take offense at any of the views
expressed in this class by the instructor or in course
materials, may I suggest: (1) try to keep an open mind (2)
reflect on
why you find certain beliefs or opinions
vexing or upsetting and use this as an opportunity for
self-exploration, to practice self-management skills and to
develop your capacity for tolerance of ideas which differ from
your own (3) remind yourself that emotions are an unreliable
guide to objective reality and that the feelings we associate
with certain ideas are often accidents of birth, culture and
personal experience (4) keep in mind that
exploring or
understanding an idea isn't the same as
approving
of or
accepting it and (5) engage the instructor in
civil discussion or debate in class sessions (in the case of
face-to-face classes) or privately in office hours.
Another relevant section of the faculty contract is Section
16.3, Civic Life, which states, "
Each faculty member is
also a citizen of his or her nation, state and community;
and when he or she speaks, writes or acts as such shall be
free from institutional censorship." This means that
faculty have an absolute
right to express themselves outside the
classroom without fear of retribution from the
Administration. Therefore, if you encounter the
instructor outside the classroom, acting in his capacity as a
private citizen, you should recognize that
his views do
not necessarily represent those of the college and that
the college recognizes his right to speak, write
and act according to the truth as he sees it and the
dictates of his own conscience.
ACADEMIC FREEDOM OF STUDENTS: "Each faculty member is
entitled to and responsible for protecting freedom in the
classroom in discussion and presentation of subject matter."
-- Collective Bargaining Agreement between the Lane Community
College Educational Association and Board of Education,
Section 15.2. Voicing an opinion that differs from that
expressed by the instructor in face-to-face sessions or online
forums will never be penalized, though there may be occasions
when debate must be curtailed in the interest of adequately
covering course material.
The instructor encourages the
voicing of dissenting opinions, especially on controversial
issues and when backed by convincing reasons and supporting
evidence. This enlivens class, provides an alternative
viewpoint, fosters critical thinking and may end up
enlightening the instructor, who occasionally realizes he has
been wrong. Please couch dissenting opinions in a constructive
and respectful manner in order to keep the exchange of ideas
civil. This particular class uses recordings from the
face-to-face classes and has weekly quizzes in lieu of online
forums, but alternative viewpoints are always welcome in Zoom
office hours Tu 4-5pm and Th 7-8pm. Click the link near the
top of this page to connect.
USE OF HUMOR: The instructor frequently employs humor
to lighten the mood as well as to illustrate points, add color
and make learning fun. This should in no way be interpreted as
disparaging any individual or group. Students will always be
treated with the utmost respect and will never be mocked or
ridiculed.
CONCERNS: I want this class to be a positive learning
experience for you. If, at any time, you have a concern,
grievance or complaint about the course,
please speak with
me about it directly in office hours or via Moodle
message. You have my personal guarantee that I will hear you
out, reflect carefully on what you have to say and that it
will have no bearing on your grade. Because the class uses
objective testing (with a record of scores on the server), you
have additional protection. My only request is that, if I have
some feedback for you, you consider it in the same spirit. I'd
rather correct any problems than have you be disgruntled for
the rest of the term (which is likely to negatively affect
your performance in the class) only to complain about it in
student evaluations. Why not alert me to a problem when I can
actually do something about it? In the unlikely event that you
remain dissatisfied, you can still take your concerns to the
Dean of the
Social
Science Division. I am a reasonable, fair and kind human
being and care about my students, so I'm sure we will be able
to work something out. The Dean's first suggestion will
probably be that the three of us meeting to discuss the issue.
He is a busy man doing important work for the college. Why not
see if we can work it out between us first? Addressing any
concerns early, honestly and directly will result in a better
outcome for both of us.
WHAT PHILOSOPHY IS: Philosophy
is the attempt to come to a systematic understanding
of the objective world through the use of reason. The
philosophical approach assumes a commitment to follow
the truth wherever it leads, however uncomfortable it
may make us and in spite of what we may wish to be
true. It strives for logical consistency and agreement
with the empirical evidence. Philosophy is about
asking questions, especially questions no one else
wants to ask. Philosophy even questions the
unquestionable, including things considered to be
"common sense," such as the existence of an external
world of matter, free will, God, the soul, an
afterlife, or the existence of universal, objective
moral values (or perhaps the unquestionable certainty
of our age is the dogma that morality is culturally
relative or completely subjective). Philosophy uses
conceptual analysis as its primary tool. Properly
analyzing concepts requires the rigorous definition of
terms, so the precise use of language is very
important to philosophers, or at least to the good
ones. This goes all the way back to Socrates. Fuzzy
language evinces fuzzy thinking.
WHAT PHILOSOPHY IS NOT: Philosophy is not
about exploring your "personal beliefs." Nor is it
about your feelings, as reality is not based on your
subjective emotional state. Philosophy is not about
your identity, your sex, your gender, your sexual
orientation, your culture or your "
race."
It's not about your faith or "how you were raised."
Try to avoid thinking in these terms and using
subjective phrases like "personally" and "in my
personal opinion" when doing philosophy. Philosophy
(and indeed all academic discourse) is about your
impersonal
opinion, i.e. your opinion backed by reasons and
evidence. Although there is an historical tradition
associated with philosophy, it is not primarily about
history, and even though understanding their
historical or cultural context may help us understand
the ideas of particular philosophers, it is
the
ideas themselves with which philosophy is
concerned.
CONTRIBUTIONS OF WOMEN AND NON-WESTERN
CULTURES: There were few women philosophers
until the beginning of the feminist movement in the
19th century. This was true of most other academic
fields due to the institutionalization of pre-modern
gender roles. Because this is a survey class concerned
with major historical figures and basic concepts in
ethics, we won't be reading many women philosophers.
This should in no way be seen as casting aspersions on
women as a class of people.
Along those same lines, for various complex historical
and cultural reasons, philosophy emerged and
flourished in the West and is the heritage of Western
Civilization. It uniquely sowed the seeds for the
scientific and subsequent industrial revolutions in
Western Europe, leading to our modern technological
world. It is important to understand that "Western" is
just a conventional term for ideas which first emerged
in Western Europe. An idea's place of origin or the
particulars of the person who first developed or
expounded it has nothing whatever to do with its truth
value or importance in increasing human understanding.
Newton and Leibniz discovered calculus around the same
time and each accused the other of stealing his
discovery. Yet calculus is neither essentially a
British idea nor a German idea, nor is it a European
or "white male" idea. Who was first to discover it,
where he lived and the details of his ancestry and
nationality are irrelevant to the validity and
usefulness of calculus. So it is with all intellectual
discoveries and theoretical innovations, including
those concerning the foundations of knowledge.
CATALOG DESCRIPTION: Theories of knowledge
(epistemology) address issues such as the nature of
truth and rational justification, whether knowledge
comes primarily through reason or the senses and how
our common sense beliefs about the world might be
proven. Additional topics may include how much control
we have over our beliefs, whether duties or rights
apply to beliefs and the relationship between faith
and reason.
COURSE OBJECTIVES: The objectives are
this course are for students to (1) come to a clearer
understanding of epistemological issues through the
study of classical and contemporary theories (2)
acquire some factual knowledge about the history of
philosophy and important philosophical thinkers (3)
come to their own conclusions about which theories are
best or most likely to be true, even if those
conclusions are of a tentative nature (4) acquire
critical and analytical reasoning skills along the way
(5) apply conclusions about the nature of knowledge to
their present way of assessing evidence and
worldviews.
COURSE REQUIREMENTS
PODCAST
QUIZZES
|
Weeks
1-9: Due before Sunday 11:59pm
Week 10: Due before Thursday
11:59pm
|
20%
of grade
|
FIRST
MIDTERM EXAM |
Opens: Monday, April 27 at 9am
Closes: Monday, May 4 at 11:59pm |
20% of grade
|
SECOND
MIDTERM EXAM
|
Opens:
Monday, May 18 at 9am
Closes: Tuesday, May 26 at 11:59pm |
20%
of grade |
COMPREHENSIVE
MIDTERM
|
Opens:
Wednesday, May 27 at 9am
Closes: Friday, June 5 at 11:59pm |
20%
of grade
|
FINAL EXAM |
Opens: Monday, June 8 at 9am
Closes: Friday, June 12 at
11:59pm
|
20% of grade
|
READING: It is important to read the
material in order to perform well on exams.
AUDIO PODCASTS: Each week you will listen to
the lecture/discussion from the face-to-face classroom
section from last Spring. These audio podcasts will
will help explain the reading and course concepts. Not
listening to these recordings would be the equivalent
of not going to a face to face class and attempting to
pass by simply reading the textbook. There will be
some material presented in these recordings which will
be tested on but which is not in the readings and
videos provided in Moodle. You can stream them from
Moodle or download them to your computer or phone from
the link in the Course Information and Resources
section and listen to them while doing routine
household chores, exercising, and so on, though you
may find it helpful to take some notes as you listen.
Most sessions will refer to Powerpoint slides or
whiteboard notes, included with the recordings.
PODCAST QUIZZES: To incentivize timely
listening to the audio podcasts, a quiz will be due
each Sunday before 11:59pm during Weeks 1-9,
Thursday11:59pm during Week 10. I will ask questions
about the podcast which you should be able to answer
if you listened attentively.
EXAMS: The
exam format will be multiple choice and true/false
questions.
The final will not be
comprehensive.
Each
exam has a study guide linked in Moodle. Read the
questions and make sure you can answer each of them.
You may even want to write out the answers, which you
can consult while taking the exam. If you don't know
the answer to a particular question, search the
relevant section of the online textbook, the
Powerpoints, whiteboard captures and your notes from
the audio podcasts for the answer. If you are still
unsure or have questions about the reading or
podcasts, attend the Zoom tutoring hours listed above.
Even if you don't have any particular questions, you
are encouraged to attend Zoom tutoring hours for help
in doing your very best on the exams. If you still
have questions, attend the Zoom office hours of the
instructor listed above. Also, make sure to take the
short practice quizzes each week.
Once you take the exam, you'll immediately receive
your score and see the questions you missed, along
with the correct answers. Please give yourself time to
review the exam right after you take it, since
you
will not be able to review your exam once you close
out the window. Reviewing your first two
midterm exams will be helpful to you when you take
the Comprehensive Midterm Exam, which will cover the
same material.
The lowest of your three midterm exam scores
is automatically dropped (note that this does not
include the Final Exam). This means that
even if you get an F on the First Midterm Exam, you
can get some help with the class, figure out where you
went wrong, apply yourself, and possibly end up with
an A in the class.
You will have a week to take the First
and Second Midterm, nine days for Comprehensive
Midterm and five days for Final Exam. Exams are taken
via Moodle with a time limit of one hour. The opening
and closing times of exams are listed in the table
above and in the course outline at the end of the
syllabus. Clicking on any exam in the main course view
in Moodle will also show you the opening and closing
dates as well as the chapters and weeks it covers.
EXAM DEADLINE POLICY:
Since you will have at least a week to take each
midterm, you will be expected to meet the deadline,
however, you may contact the philosophy tutor via
Moodle message (
not email) to request an
extension without penalty. Please
include
the class, the exam and the date
you would like it extended to in your
message.
Since there is no separate final exam
week, the final closes Friday of Week Ten and no
extensions are possible past then. If you miss
the deadline for the final due to some unforeseen
circumstance or emergency situation, contact the
instructor via Moodle message for options ASAP.
Since I have the gradebook set to ignore empty grades,
if you miss an exam, just like a missed forum post,
you won't see the effect on your grade until the end
of the term when I turn that setting off. If you got
an 80% on the First Midterm but that's the only exam
you take, the gradebook might tell you that you have a
80 in the course, or even an 84% if you didn't do any
forum posts either, but your grade would be 16%, an F.
Again, Moodle will tell you your grade
based on
the assignments completed so far. Anything you
don't complete will be converted to a zero at the end
of the term. Make sure to complete all of the exams by
the deadlines!
GRADING:
There is no curve. At the end of the term, the class
will be graded on the following absolute scale, with
course totals rounded up to the nearest
whole number:
A+ 97% -100% |
A 93% - 96%
|
A- 90% - 92% |
B+ 87% - 89% |
B 83% - 86% |
B- 80% - 82% |
C+ 77% - 79% |
C 73% - 76% |
C- 70% - 72% |
D+ 67% - 69% |
D 63% - 66% |
D- 60% - 62% |
|
F 0% - 59% |
|
GETTING
HELP WITH THE CLASS: If you are having
difficulties with the class, please see the philosophy
tutor as soon as possible. The
tutor's Zoom office hours are at the top of this syllabus
and linked near the top of the main course page in Moodle.
The tutor can go over your exam with you and help you to
improve your grade on the next one as well as on the
Comprehensive Midterm Exam. If you have questions about
basic concepts or the study questions, please see the tutor
before seeing the instructor. You can earn extra credit for
each tutor visit of at least half an hour, up to a total of
three.
EARLY OUTREACH AND REFERRAL (EOR) PROGRAM: At Lane
Community College, we want every student to be successful.
The Early
Outreach and Referral (EOR) Program is a campus-wide
effort to support students early in the term when they first
begin experiencing difficulty in a class. If I see you are
having difficulty in this class (ex. missing classes,
missing assignments, and/or receiving low test or assignment
scores) I may refer you to our Early Outreach Specialist.
Once referred, the Early Outreach Specialist will follow up
with you by phone or email to find out how to best support
you by connecting you with necessary resources and helping
you develop and implement a success plan, which may include
individual tutoring or other services. Please respond to
these messages. Our current specialist, Mike Walker is
really nice, a good listener and has helped many struggling
students to succeed. If he contacts you, let him help.
ADVANCED QUESTIONS: If you have a particular issue
from the readings, audio podcasts or PowerPoints which you
would like to explore, discuss or perhaps debate in more
depth than is practical in Moodle messages, please visit me
during my zoom office hours. I am also happy to help clear
up any questions you may still have after seeing the tutor
first.
TECHNOLOGY
USE AND HELP: This is an online course.
It requires you to use (but not necessarily own) a
computer, tablet or smart phone with access to the
internet. The
syllabus, schedule, announcements, supplementary
material and resources, quizzes, exams and grades
are all distributed via Moodle.
Campus labs are staffed with people who can help you
if you are new to computing devices or have
difficulty using them. Contact the Student
Help Desk (SHeD) or call them at 463-3333 for
assistance with all of your education-related
technology questions.